Skip to content
Wort&Keg

Roundup

The Best Homebrew Cleaners and Sanitizers

Two chemicals do almost all of the work. The rest of this category is foam management, draft lines, and not scrubbing kegs by hand any more.

ByBrijon M.

Last updated

How we pick

The short answer

Most homebrewers need exactly two products: an alkaline wash like Five Star PBW to clean, and a no-rinse acid sanitizer like Star San to sanitize. Add Saniclean when you recirculate through a pump, a line cleaning kit once you go to draft, and a recirculating washer once hand-scrubbing kegs gets old.

Container of powdered alkaline brewery cleaner beside sanitizer

DisclosureWe earn a commission on qualifying purchases made through links on this page, at no extra cost to you. It does not change what we recommend or how we rank it -- here is how we pick and here is the full disclosure.

At a glance

Quick picks

#ProductBest forPrice
1
Container of powdered alkaline brewery cleaner

Best overall cleaner

Five Star PBW Alkaline Brewery Wash

An alkaline, non-caustic powder that lifts dried krausen and beerstone off stainless, PET and glass without scrubbing, which is the whole point -- a scratched fermenter is a contamination risk forever.

Everything that touches wort or beer, before it is sanitized
2
Bottle of no-rinse acid sanitizer for brewing

Best sanitizer overall

Five Star Star San Sanitizer

Acid-anionic, no-rinse, one to two minutes of contact at roughly 1 oz per 5 gallons. The dose economy is the real story: a bottle makes an enormous number of gallons of solution, so cost per batch is close to nothing.

Fermenters, hoses, bottling gear, anything post-boil
3
Bottle of low-foam acid sanitizer concentrate

Best low-foam sanitizer

Five Star Saniclean Low-Foam Sanitizer

The same acid-anionic chemistry as Star San without the foam, at 1 oz per 3 gallons and 2 to 3 minutes of contact. If you own a pump, this is the version that should be going through it.

Recirculating through pumps, chillers and draft lines
4
Corny keg inverted over a recirculating cleaning washer basin

Best upgrade once kegs pile up

Mark II Keg and Carboy Washer

A submersible pump fires cleaning solution up into an inverted keg or carboy and recirculates it, so the wash happens while you do something else. Hose barbs and a T adapter put tubing through the same cycle.

Brewers running three or more kegs and carboys through a cycle
5
Beer line cleaning kit with a pump bottle and brushes

Best for draft lines

Beer Line Cleaning Kit

Beer lines grow biofilm whether or not the beer tastes fine, and a pressurized bottle or hand pump pushes alkaline line cleaner through the whole path in fifteen to twenty minutes. Faucet and shank brushes are included because that is where the buildup actually lives.

Anyone with a kegerator or keezer in service

Prices are checked on Amazon when you click. We never print a number we cannot verify.

What each product is for

PBWStar SanSaniclean
JobCleanSanitizeSanitize
FormPowderLiquidLiquid
Typical dose~1 oz per gal1 oz per 5 gal1 oz per 3 gal
Contact time20-30 min soak1-2 min2-3 min
FoamModerateHeavyLow
No-rinseNoYesYes
Pump and line safeYesFoams badlyYes
Safe on soft metalsYesAvoid aluminumAvoid aluminum

An orange rule marks the better of the two on that row.

The distinction

Cleaning and sanitizing are two different jobs

This is the one thing worth getting right before spending any money. A cleaner removes soil -- dried krausen, beerstone, hop resin, the film inside a hose. A sanitizer reduces the microorganisms living on an already-clean surface to a level that will not outcompete your yeast. Neither does the other job, and a sanitizer applied to a dirty surface is close to useless because the soil physically shields what you are trying to kill.

So the order is fixed: clean, rinse, sanitize, then fill. Every product below slots into one of those steps, and the reason this category looks crowded is that manufacturers sell four variations of each step. You do not need four. You need one good cleaner, one no-rinse sanitizer, and then a specific answer for the two places those two fail -- pumps and draft lines.

Scrubbing is the other thing to avoid, and not because it is unpleasant. A green scouring pad leaves microscopic scratches in plastic and in the passive layer on stainless, and those scratches hold soil that no sanitizer can reach. That is the real argument for buying a chemical that dissolves soil rather than a tool that abrades it off, and it is why a soak-and-walk-away cleaner is worth more to a fermenter than any brush. The same logic drives the choice between stainless and plastic fermenters: scratched plastic gets retired, scratched stainless repassivates.

Criteria

What we judged these on

Cleaning chemicals are hard to review honestly because nobody can see the result. We did not culture plates or run swab tests, so the ranking rests on published manufacturer dose rates and contact times, documented material compatibility, current retail availability, and whether a product solves a problem the cheaper option genuinely cannot. Four things decided the order:

  • Dose economy, measured per gallon of solution. This is where the real cost lives, not on the shelf price. A sanitizer mixed at 1 oz per 5 gallons costs under half as much per gallon of working solution as the same-size bottle mixed at 1 oz per 3 gallons. Over a year of brewing, that difference dwarfs the gap between bottle prices.
  • Contact time you will actually respect. A one to two minute no-rinse sanitizer gets used correctly. A thirty minute requirement gets cut short, and a sanitizer used for half its contact time is a sanitizer that did not work. Short contact times are a safety feature in a real kitchen.
  • Material compatibility, as published. Acid sanitizers are not for aluminum or other soft metals. That matters if you own an aluminum kettle, and the manufacturers state it plainly, so there is no excuse for guessing.
  • Whether it fixes a real failure of the cheap option. Low-foam sanitizer and a line cleaning kit both earn their place because high-foam sanitizer in a pump and neglected biofilm in a draft line are specific, predictable problems. A recirculating washer earns its place only by buying back time, and we say so plainly rather than pretending it improves the beer.

We deliberately left out the oxygen-based household cleaners brewers sometimes substitute. They work on light soil, but dose rates are not published for brewing surfaces and several leave a chalky film that needs rinsing off -- which defeats the point. See how we pick for the full method.

The lineup

Where each product earns its place

PBW is the default cleaner because alkaline chemistry dissolves the two soils homebrewing produces -- protein from krausen and the mineral scale brewers call beerstone -- and it is non-caustic, so it will not etch the stainless or craze the PET it is sitting in. Warm water does most of the work. A fermenter filled past the krausen line with warm PBW solution and left for half an hour usually needs nothing afterwards but a rinse.

Star San is the default sanitizer for the dose economy above all else. Mixed at the published rate it works in one to two minutes and needs no rinse, and the mixed solution keeps for weeks if you made it with distilled or low-alkalinity water. The foam is not a defect in a bucket -- the foam is sanitizer, and it drains off. It is only a defect when it is trapped.

Saniclean exists for exactly that trapped case. The same family of chemistry, formulated low-foaming, published at 1 oz per 3 gallons with 2 to 3 minutes of contact. If you recirculate sanitizer through a pump, a plate chiller or a counterflow chiller, foam becomes compressible gas in a line that needs liquid, and the pump cavitates instead of pumping. Running the low-foam version is cheaper than chasing an air lock on brew day. If you have not settled which chiller you are running, the trade-offs are in immersion vs plate vs counterflow.

The washer and the line kit are stage-dependent. Nobody with one fermenter needs a recirculating washer. A brewer with four kegs, two carboys and a stack of tubing to turn around on a Sunday is buying back an hour of standing at a sink, and that is a legitimate purchase at the point it becomes true. The line cleaning kit is not optional in the same way -- if you have a kegerator in service, the lines need cleaning on a schedule whether or not anything tastes wrong, which is covered in full in best beer line cleaning kits.

Dose and contact time

The numbers that make any of this work

Under-dosing is the most common failure, and it comes from eyeballing. Star San at the published 1 oz per 5 gallons is a specific concentration chosen to hit a pH low enough to do the job; half that dose is not half as effective, it may simply be ineffective. Buy a cheap measuring cup, keep it with the chemicals, and stop guessing.

Water chemistry quietly matters too. Acid sanitizers mixed with hard, alkaline tap water go cloudy and lose working life because the alkalinity consumes the acid. Mixed with distilled or reverse-osmosis water the same solution stays clear and usable for weeks in a sealed container. If your mixed sanitizer turns milky within a day, that is your water and not a bad bottle -- discard it and mix the next batch with distilled.

Temperature belongs to the cleaner, not the sanitizer. PBW works noticeably faster warm, in the 120 to 150 F range, and that is the easiest way to shorten a soak. Hot water out of the tap is usually enough. Sanitizer does not want heat -- room temperature is fine, and very hot solution shortens its life.

Routine

A routine that fits a real brew day

  1. Clean immediately after use, not later. Fresh soil rinses off with water. The same soil dried for three days needs a long alkaline soak. This single habit saves more chemical than any purchase on this page.
  2. Soak in warm alkaline wash. Fermenter, lid, airlock, hoses, bottling wand, anything that touched wort. Half an hour is plenty for same-day soil.
  3. Rinse thoroughly. Alkaline residue and acid sanitizer react with each other, which wastes both. Rinse until the water runs clear and the surface no longer feels slick.
  4. Sanitize last, right before filling. Sanitizing something you then store for a week accomplishes nothing. Mix fresh or use kept solution that is still clear, hit the published contact time, drain, and fill without rinsing.
  5. Put draft lines on a calendar. Every two weeks of active service, with the faucet taken apart. It is twenty minutes, and it is the difference between a kegerator that pours clean beer in year three and one that does not. The whole setup is covered in the homebrew kegging setup guide.
  6. Switch to low foam once a pump is in the loop. Circulated acid sanitizer foams, and foam in a pump head means the pump is moving air instead of liquid. This is the one place the low-foam product is not optional -- see best brewing pumps for the cleaning loop it belongs to.

Mistakes

Five ways brewers waste money here

  • Buying a sanitizer to do a cleaner's job. No-rinse sanitizer poured into a dirty fermenter is money down the drain. The soil wins.
  • Scrubbing plastic. Every scratch is permanent shelter for the next infection. Soak instead, and if a PET fermenter is already scratched inside, retire it to water duty.
  • Running high-foam sanitizer through a pump. You will spend brew day priming a pump full of air rather than chilling wort.
  • Mixing sanitizer with hard tap water and keeping it. It goes cloudy, loses working life, and you end up blaming the product.
  • Buying the gallon jug first. Concentrates have a shelf life once opened and homebrew doses are tiny. A small bottle will outlast the hobby's first year, and powder that cakes is powder you throw away.

How we picked

The basis for these

Dose rates, contact times and material warnings are the manufacturers' published figures, taken from the current retail listings linked below, and availability was confirmed against those live listings at the time of writing. We have not run microbiological tests on any of these products and do not claim to; the ranking reflects published specifications, documented homebrewer practice and the cost arithmetic of dose rate. No prices are printed here -- check the current price yourself before buying.

The picks, in order

Every pick in detail

Container of powdered alkaline brewery cleaner

#1

Best overall cleaner

Entry tier

Five Star PBW Alkaline Brewery Wash

Five Star Chemicals

An alkaline, non-caustic powder that lifts dried krausen and beerstone off stainless, PET and glass without scrubbing, which is the whole point -- a scratched fermenter is a contamination risk forever.

Spec sheet

Type
Alkaline, non-caustic powdered wash
Dose
~1 oz per gal for heavy soil
Temperature
Works best warm (120-150 F)
Contact
20-30 min soak, or recirculate
Safe on
Stainless, PET, glass, silicone
Not a sanitizer
Clean first, then sanitize separately

What it is not good at

It is a cleaner, not a sanitizer, and it is not fast: plan on a 20 to 30 minute soak and warm water around 120 to 150 F to get full value. Cold-water soaks work but take longer.

Who it is for

Everything that touches wort or beer, before it is sanitized

Bottle of no-rinse acid sanitizer for brewing

#2

Best sanitizer overall

Entry tier

Five Star Star San Sanitizer

Five Star Chemicals

Acid-anionic, no-rinse, one to two minutes of contact at roughly 1 oz per 5 gallons. The dose economy is the real story: a bottle makes an enormous number of gallons of solution, so cost per batch is close to nothing.

Spec sheet

Type
Acid-anionic, no-rinse
Contact time
1-2 minutes
Dilution
1 oz per 5 gal

What it is not good at

It foams heavily. In a pump, a counterflow chiller or a draft line that foam becomes an air lock, and the standing advice not to fear the foam is only true in a bucket.

Who it is for

Fermenters, hoses, bottling gear, anything post-boil

Bottle of low-foam acid sanitizer concentrate

#3

Best low-foam sanitizer

Mid tier

Five Star Saniclean Low-Foam Sanitizer

Five Star Chemicals

The same acid-anionic chemistry as Star San without the foam, at 1 oz per 3 gallons and 2 to 3 minutes of contact. If you own a pump, this is the version that should be going through it.

Spec sheet

Type
Acid-anionic, no-rinse final rinse
Dilution
1 oz per 3 gallons of water
Contact time
2-3 minutes
Foam
Low-foaming -- built for pumps and lines
Mixed life
Effective about a week once mixed
Not for
Aluminum and other soft metals

What it is not good at

A smaller dose yield than Star San for the same bottle size, so it costs more per gallon of solution. Not for aluminum or other soft metals, and mixed solution is good for roughly a week.

Who it is for

Recirculating through pumps, chillers and draft lines

Corny keg inverted over a recirculating cleaning washer basin

#4

Best upgrade once kegs pile up

Mid tier

Mark II Keg and Carboy Washer

Mark II

A submersible pump fires cleaning solution up into an inverted keg or carboy and recirculates it, so the wash happens while you do something else. Hose barbs and a T adapter put tubing through the same cycle.

Spec sheet

Basin
One-piece high-density polyethylene reservoir
Pump
Submersible, 500 gallons per hour
Method
Vertical jet nozzle, solution recirculates
Fits
Corny kegs, glass and PET carboys, buckets
Included
Two tube barbs and a T adapter for hoses
Use with
Alkaline wash, line cleaner or sanitizer

What it is not good at

A three-figure purchase to solve a problem a long-handled brush solves for a few dollars -- it buys time and shoulder joints, not better beer. It also wants a sink or drain nearby and will not clean a keg dip tube on its own.

Who it is for

Brewers running three or more kegs and carboys through a cycle

Beer line cleaning kit with a pump bottle and brushes

#5

Best for draft lines

Entry tier

Beer Line Cleaning Kit

Mark's Keg Wash / Kegco

Beer lines grow biofilm whether or not the beer tastes fine, and a pressurized bottle or hand pump pushes alkaline line cleaner through the whole path in fifteen to twenty minutes. Faucet and shank brushes are included because that is where the buildup actually lives.

Spec sheet

Method
Hand pump or CO2-pressurized bottle
Cleaner
Alkaline line cleaner concentrate
Fittings
Ball lock disconnect and faucet thread adapters
Brushes
Faucet and shank brushes included
Cycle time
15-20 minutes for a two-tap system
Frequency
Every two weeks of active service

What it is not good at

It needs doing every couple of weeks of active service, which is the part people quietly skip. The cheapest kits use thin tubing that kinks, and no kit cleans a faucet you never take apart.

Who it is for

Anyone with a kegerator or keezer in service

FAQ

Questions brewers actually ask

Do I need both a cleaner and a sanitizer for homebrewing?

Yes. They do different jobs and neither substitutes for the other. A cleaner dissolves soil such as dried krausen and beerstone; a sanitizer reduces microorganisms on an already-clean surface. A sanitizer applied over soil is largely wasted because the soil shields what you are trying to kill, so the order is always clean, rinse, sanitize, fill.

What is the difference between Star San and Saniclean?

Both are acid-anionic no-rinse sanitizers from Five Star. Star San is mixed at about 1 oz per 5 gallons with one to two minutes of contact and foams heavily. Saniclean is mixed at 1 oz per 3 gallons with two to three minutes of contact and is formulated low-foaming, which is what you want when the solution has to move through a pump, a plate chiller or a draft line.

Why does my Star San solution go cloudy?

Hard, alkaline tap water. The alkalinity in the water consumes the acid, so the solution clouds and loses working life within a day or so. Mixed with distilled or reverse-osmosis water the same solution stays clear and usable for weeks in a sealed container. Cloudy solution should be discarded rather than topped up.

Can I use a scouring pad on my fermenter?

Avoid it. Abrasive pads leave microscopic scratches in plastic and in the passive layer on stainless, and those scratches hold soil that no sanitizer can reach. Soak in warm alkaline wash instead and let the chemistry lift the soil. A PET fermenter that is already scratched inside is best retired from beer duty.

Is a keg and carboy washer worth buying?

Only once the volume justifies it. It recirculates cleaning solution up into an inverted keg or carboy so the wash happens unattended, and it will clean hoses through the included barbs. What it buys is time, not better beer, so it makes sense for a brewer turning around several kegs and carboys at once and makes no sense for someone with a single fermenter.

Sources

Read next

More on brew day gear

Container of powdered alkaline brewery cleaner beside a fermenter

Guide

How to Clean a Fermenter

Dump, disassemble, soak, rinse: the fermenter cleaning routine for stainless, PET and glass vessels.

View all Brew Day Gear →